If you're a key lime pie lover in Louisville, you're in luck. This city has some of the best spots for this tangy dessert.
Whether you're in the mood for a classic slice or want to try something new, there's a place for everyone.
But with so many options, it can be tough to decide where to go. That's where this guide comes in — we've scoured the city for the best key lime pies, so you don't have to.
We've tried them all, from the traditional to the unique, and have narrowed down the top picks.
In this post, we'll take you on a tour of the best places for key lime pie in Louisville. We'll explore the flavors and textures of each slice, the ambiance of each location, and what makes each spot unique.
Whether you're a local or a visitor, we've got you covered. So sit back, grab a fork, and get ready to indulge in the best key lime pies in Louisville.
1. Crumbl Cookies – Middletown
Crumbl Cookies – Middletown is a delightful bakery that offers a rotating menu of delicious cookies.
The key lime pie cookies are a must-try for anyone who loves this classic dessert. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the cookies are always fresh and baked to perfection.
While the location is small, the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. The prices are reasonable for the high quality of the cookies.
It's no wonder why Crumbl Cookies – Middletown is a popular spot for dessert lovers.
2. Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse
Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse offers an outstanding dining experience in downtown Louisville. The key lime pie is a must-try dessert that will leave you wanting more.
The restaurant's slow-paced dining environment and excellent service make for a memorable experience.
The menu includes a variety of dishes, including steaks, seafood, and sides, all prepared to perfection.
The rooftop setting adds to the ambiance of the restaurant, making it an excellent choice for a special occasion. Be sure to make a reservation in advance as this popular spot fills up quickly.
3. Sweet Havana
If you're looking for a place to satisfy your sweet tooth, Sweet Havana is a must-visit spot.
This Cuban bakery and dessert restaurant offers a wide selection of pastries and cakes, including their famous key lime pie.
The staff is friendly and the ambiance is cozy, making it a great place to relax and indulge in some delicious treats.
Don't miss out on this hidden gem!
4. The Comfy Cow
The Comfy Cow is a cheery ice cream chain that offers a variety of creative, rotating flavors.
They frequently use local ingredients in their treats, making them a must-visit for foodies. In addition to ice cream, they also sell ice cream pies and local cookies.
While the prices are a bit high, it's worth it for the quality ingredients and rich flavor.
The staff is helpful and knowledgeable, and the vintage eclectic design of the store adds to the fun atmosphere. If you're a key lime pie fan, be sure to give theirs a try.
5. Georgia's Sweet Potato Pie Company
Georgia's Sweet Potato Pie Company is a must-visit place for anyone looking for delicious key lime pie.
Apart from pies, the bakery also offers a range of other treats like cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake, and ice cream.
Everything is made using sweet potato, which gives them a unique flavor that is hard to resist.
The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the bakery a great place to relax and enjoy a sweet treat. The bakery is highly recommended for anyone looking for a unique dessert experience.
6. Redlands Grill
Redlands Grill is a contemporary American eatery that serves wood-fired American fare in a modern space with a bar.
This place is a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious key lime pie. The pie is made with fresh limes and has the perfect balance of tangy and sweet flavors.
The crust is buttery and crumbly, making it the perfect complement to the creamy filling. The staff is friendly and attentive, making the dining experience enjoyable.
The atmosphere is comfortable and inviting, making it a great spot for a casual lunch or a night out. Redlands Grill is definitely worth a visit for anyone craving a slice of delectable key lime pie.
7. Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen
If you're in the mood for some delicious key lime pie, then Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen is the place to be.
This bakery serves up traditional desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. The housemade pies are a must-try, especially the key lime pie which is perfectly tart and sweet.
The ice cream is also a crowd-pleaser, with a variety of flavors to choose from. The staff is friendly and willing to provide recommendations, making the experience even better.
Stop by Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen for a tasty treat that won't disappoint.
8. CASK Southern Kitchen & Bar
CASK Southern Kitchen & Bar is a must-visit place for anyone who loves key lime pie.
The pie is one of their specialties, and it does not disappoint. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the filling is tangy, sweet, and creamy.
The restaurant also offers a great selection of cocktails, and the staff is friendly and welcoming.
The atmosphere is cozy and warm, making it a great spot for a night out with friends or a date. Don't miss out on this hidden gem!
9. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill is a contemporary grill chain that offers a seafood-centric menu, including their famous key lime pie.
The restaurant boasts a welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff.
The menu offers a variety of options, including seafood, steak, and gluten-free options.
The key lime pie is a must-try for dessert lovers. The restaurant is perfect for casual dining and special occasions.
10. Rumors Restaurant
Rumors Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving the perfect slice of key lime pie.
This seafood restaurant offers a laid-back atmosphere with a beachside feel, perfect for a casual dining experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, and the food is prepared fresh once ordered.
While the menu offers a variety of options, the key lime pie is definitely the star of the show. It's a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth.
The restaurant also offers free wifi, making it a great spot for a lunch meeting or to catch up on work while enjoying a delicious dessert.
11. Doc Crow's
Doc Crow's is a spacious eatery serving up Southern classics like BBQ and oysters.
But what really stands out is their key lime pie. It's tart, creamy, and has the perfect graham cracker crust.
The atmosphere is lively, and the service is friendly.
Whether you're in the mood for a full meal or just a slice of pie, Doc Crow's is definitely worth a visit.
12. Joe's Crab Shack
Joe's Crab Shack is a casual seafood chain that offers American comfort dishes and seafood options like crab buckets and stuffed shrimp.
If you're looking for key lime pie, then Joe's Crab Shack is a great place to go.
Their key lime pie is a must-try, with a creamy texture and a tangy flavor that will leave you wanting more.
Whether you're in the mood for a slice of pie or a full meal, Joe's Crab Shack has something for everyone. With friendly service and a fun atmosphere, it's a great place to stop by for a delicious treat.
